CHOICE OF CRIMINOLOGICAL MODALITIES AS A FACTOR OF FREQUENCY OF AMENDMENT TO THE CRIMINAL CODE AND PENITENTIARY CODE

Year: 
2023

Article:

Issue: 
5

UDC: 
343
DOI: 
10.34076/22196838_2023_5_26
Author(s): 

Kokotova Daria

Associate professor, Ural State Law University named after V. F. Yakovlev, candidate of legal sciences, ORCID: 0000-0001-9455-5864, e-mail: darya.kokotova@mail.ru

Author(s): 
Kokotova Daria
Abstract: 

The number of laws on amendments to the Criminal Code is significantly higher than in the Penitentiary Code, both for the entire existence of the codes and for each individual year. In this article we want verify, does this data indicate that the Criminal Code is amended more frequently than the Penitentiary Code: are the acts comparable by the period of their existence, their volume and object of regulation; are the units of observation correct? Also, objective of this article is to find the reasons of such difference. On the base of generalization of information about quantity and content of legal acts, adopted in 2018–2022, author conclude that the difference between frequency of amendment to codes is a real fact. It is determined by the characteristics of rules, but not the properties of relations. This difference is determined principally by amendments to the Special part of the Criminal Code and it specific. The reason of this situation is the choice of the different fundamental criminological modalities for each of the codes. The classical school and the modality of retribution are fundament of the Criminal Code, and the Penitentiary Code is based on the positive school.

Key words: 

classical school, modality of retribution, positive school, Criminal Code, Penitentiary Code, frequency of amendment

For citation: 

Kokotova D. (2023) Choice of criminological modalities as a factor of frequency of amendment to the Criminal Code and Penitentiary Code. In Elektronnoe prilozhenie k «Rossiiskomu yuridicheskomu zhurnalu», no. 5, pp. 26–40, DOI: http://doi.org/10.34076/22196838_2023_5_26.

Text of the article: 

Publication date: 
Tuesday, 05.03.2024

English