CLINICAL RECOMMENDATIONS IN THE MECHANISM OF BRINGING TO CIVIL LIABILITY FOR IMPROPER FULFILLMENT OF OBLIGATIONS TO PROVIDE MEDICAL SERVICES

Year: 
2026

Article:

Issue: 
3

UDC: 
347
DOI: 
10.34076/22196838_2026_3_79
Author(s): 

Murzin Dmitry

Leading researcher, project office «Legal genomics: an interdisciplinary project in the field of legal support for the use of genetic technologies and genomic information», Ural State Law University named after V. F. Yakovlev (Yekaterinburg), professor, Ural branch of the Presidential Research Center for Private Law named after S. S. Alekseev, doctor of legal sciences, ORCID: 0000-0002-0384-4351, e-mail: agaety@mail.ru

Author(s): 
Murzin Dmitry
Abstract: 

The article discusses the legal nature of the clinical guidelines used in the provision of medical care (in fulfilling the obligation to provide medical services). The article refutes the qualification of clinical recommendations as a normative source (custom, «soft law», etc.). It is proposed to consider following clinical recommendations solely from the standpoint of the conditions of civil liability of a medical organization for inadequate quality of medical services. The importance of using clinical recommendations is seen as a criterion of the prudence and care of the medical organization when choosing a treatment option, which implies in certain cases the refusal to use such recommendations. It is concluded that it is necessary to renounce the innocent responsibility of a medical organization in both contractual and tort relationships

Key words: 

clinical recommendations, medical services, civil liability, effort, guilt

For citation: 

Murzin D. (2026) Clinical recommendations in the mechanism of bringing to civil liability for improper fulfillment of obligations to provide medical services. In Elektronnoe prilozhenie k «Rossiiskomu yuridicheskomu zhurnalu», no. 3, pp. 79–88, DOI: http://doi.org/10.34076/ 22196838_2026_3_79.

Text of the article: 
English